Medicare Plan Benefits
Free Medicare Consultations | Family Owned | Over 70 Years of Combined Experience
Free Medicare Consultations
Over 60 Years’ Combined Experience
Family Owned
Get the Most Out of Your Medicare Years
Confused about choosing Medicare coverage options? We are here to answer all your questions and help you through the application process. At American Benefits Agency, we don't promote specific carriers, but educate you on how to choose the insurance that fulfills your needs. Contact our locally and family-owned business for FREE education on Medicare and more information.
American Benefits Agency represents most of the companies in South Dakota, North Dakota, Wyoming, and Nebraska that sell Medicare Supplement and Part D drug plans, including the special COST plans available from MEDICA Insurance Company. Our services are available around the clock.
Types of Medicare Insurance
- Medicare Supplement
- Medicare Advantage
- Medicare Part D prescription plans
- Medicare Cost Plans

Medicare Plans Tailored to Your Needs
Choosing the right Medicare coverage can feel overwhelming. With so many plan types, providers, and enrollment rules, it’s easy to feel uncertain about which option best supports your health and budget. That’s where our agency steps in. As a trusted local broker, we’re here to simplify the Medicare process for you. From explaining coverage differences to helping you compare providers, our goal is to make sure you feel confident in your decisions. When you’re searching for Medicare insurance in Sturgis, SD or the surrounding areas, you’ll find that working with American Benefits Agency means peace of mind and a partner who truly understands what matters most to you.
Understanding the Different Medicare Options
Medicare isn’t a one-size-fits-all program. There are different plans that cover different needs, and each one comes with its own set of benefits and considerations. Let's walk through these options in a straightforward way so you can decide with confidence.
Medicare Supplement Plans
Also known as Medigap, Medicare Supplement plans are designed to cover the gaps in Original Medicare. They help with out-of-pocket costs like copayments, coinsurance, and deductibles, which can add up quickly without additional coverage. These plans are especially helpful for people who want predictable healthcare expenses and peace of mind knowing surprise costs won’t derail their financial security.
Medicare Advantage Plans
Medicare Advantage, or Part C, is an all-in-one alternative to Original Medicare. These plans are offered by private insurance companies approved by Medicare and often include extras like dental, vision, hearing, and wellness benefits. For clients who want comprehensive coverage under a single plan, Advantage plans can be an excellent choice. Our team helps compare Advantage options so you can find one that fits your lifestyle and budget.
Medicare Part D Prescription Drug Plans
Prescription medications are a critical part of healthcare for many seniors, and that’s where Part D comes in. These plans are specifically designed to reduce the cost of prescription drugs and provide coverage for both generic and brand-name medications. Without Part D, medication expenses can become overwhelming. We help you compare formularies and costs so you don’t pay more than you need to for essential prescriptions.
Medicare Cost Plans
Though not as common, Medicare Cost Plans may be an option depending on where you live. These plans combine features of Medicare Advantage with the flexibility to keep using Original Medicare if you prefer. They’re a good choice for some individuals, but it’s important to fully understand eligibility and how they compare to other Medicare solutions. That’s where our expertise as a broker comes in—we help you evaluate whether a Cost Plan is right for you.
Common Misconceptions About Medicare
Many people step into Medicare with misconceptions that lead to frustration or missed opportunities. Clearing up these misunderstandings early can save you both time and money. Here are some of the most common myths we help debunk:
- Medicare covers everything: Original Medicare doesn’t cover everything. Services like dental, vision, hearing aids, and long-term care are often left out without supplemental coverage.
- Medicare is free: While some parts of Medicare may not have a premium, most coverage involves costs like deductibles, copayments, and prescription expenses.
- You can enroll anytime: Enrollment is limited to specific periods. Missing these deadlines can result in penalties or delayed coverage.
- All plans are the same: Coverage varies widely between plans, providers, and locations. That’s why comparing options is so important.
Why It’s Smart to Get Help With Medicare Plans
Medicare is filled with fine print, deadlines, and details that can easily be overlooked. While some people try to go it alone, this approach often leads to costly mistakes or missed opportunities for better coverage. Working with an experienced broker makes the process smoother and more reliable, and it helps ensure that your healthcare plan actually fits
your life.
Avoiding Costly Mistakes
Enrolling too late, choosing a plan that doesn’t cover necessary medications, or failing to compare provider networks are all mistakes we see people make. These errors can have long-term financial consequences. By partnering with us, you’ll avoid the pitfalls and gain confidence that your coverage is both affordable and reliable. This is especially important if you’re searching for Medicare insurance in Sturgis, SD or the nearby areas, where plan availability and costs may differ from other areas.
Matching Coverage to Your Lifestyle
Not everyone needs the same type of coverage. Someone managing chronic conditions might prioritize prescription coverage, while an active retiree may want access to fitness benefits. Our agency helps you weigh these factors so your plan truly reflects your lifestyle. We don’t just point you to a plan—we match you to the coverage that helps you thrive.
The Advantages of Working With Our Agency
You have plenty of options when it comes to Medicare, but not every agency offers the same level of dedication and care. Our agency has built its reputation on providing personalized, trustworthy service that puts clients first. Here’s why working with us makes all the difference:

- Over 70 years of combined experience: Our team’s extensive knowledge allows us to guide you through Medicare with confidence and expertise.
- Free Medicare consultations: You’ll never pay to learn about your options. We believe education should come without a price tag.
- Broker advantage: Because we work with multiple providers, you’ll never feel boxed in by one company’s offerings. Our goal is to connect you with the plan that best fits your needs and budget.
Personalized Support for Medicare Insurance in Sturgis, SD
At American Benefits Agency, we understand that navigating Medicare can be overwhelming. That’s why we’re here to offer clear guidance and personal service every step of the way. Whether you're new to Medicare or reviewing your current plan, we can help you explore your options and find coverage that fits your health and budget needs. Our team is experienced in providing Medicare insurance in Sturgis, SD, and we’re committed to making the process easier for you. Let us help you feel confident in your Medicare decisions with trusted advice and local support tailored just for you.
Whether you’re enrolling for the first time or reconsidering your options during open enrollment, our agency is here to make the process simple, stress-free, and empowering. If you’ve been searching for
Medicare insurance in Sturgis, SD or the nearby regions, our team is ready to help you explore every option with clarity and care.
We Are a Family-Owned Company
American Benefits Agency specializes in health and life insurance products for people of all ages. You can trust in a family-owned and operated company. Contact us for an appointment and learn what makes us the first choice for Medicare Insurance in Sturgis, SD.
Share On: